Maximizing Recovery. Minimizing Risk.

Leveraging Opportunity

The Challenges of Converting Existing Buildings to Residential Units

On Behalf of | Feb 13, 2025 | Construction And Development |

Real estate development is a potentially lucrative endeavor. Developers acquire unimproved property or unused real estate and make improvements that ultimately generate profits and create useful real property. While development often focuses on unimproved acreage and the creation of new commercial or residential structures, it can also involve renovating existing buildings for different uses.

In recent years, converting unused buildings originally constructed for business purposes into residential units has gained popularity. For decades, developers have transformed industrial spaces and old warehouses into trendy lofts and apartments. Today, as office space demand shifts, more developers are looking to acquire unused commercial buildings and repurpose them into multi-unit residential properties, like condos or apartments. However, several significant obstacles can make these conversion projects challenging.

Unique Infrastructure Requirements

Converting a commercial building into residential units requires significant modifications to existing infrastructure. Offices and industrial properties have entirely different structural and utility needs compared to residential buildings. Compliance with residential codes involves upgrading entrances, exits, electrical systems, HVAC, plumbing, and insulation. These changes often require substantial investment, making financial feasibility a major consideration.

In some cases, the cost of retrofitting an existing building to meet modern residential standards can rival or exceed the cost of constructing a new residential building from scratch. Developers must carefully analyze the financial implications of infrastructure upgrades before committing to a conversion project.

Zoning Challenges 

Zoning laws dictate how properties can be used, and converting a building from commercial to residential use often requires rezoning or securing a variance. This process can be lengthy, complex, and sometimes met with opposition from local authorities or community members, delaying project timelines.

The financial impact of zoning challenges can be significant. Delays in approvals may increase carrying costs, and additional legal or consulting fees can strain budgets. Developers must account for these costs when determining whether a project is financially viable. Even after securing the necessary approvals, zoning restrictions may limit the number or type of residential units that can be created, further affecting profitability.

Insurance-Related Issues 

Insurance is another major challenge in building conversions. Developers often struggle to obtain adequate insurance coverage for conversion projects, as insurers may be hesitant to cover unforeseen risks associated with repurposing older structures. Additionally, even when coverage is in place, insurers may resist paying claims related to construction delays, pre-existing structural issues, or other unexpected complications.

 

Several insurance risks are associated with converting unused office space into residential units. Structural deficiencies discovered during renovations can lead to costly claims, while changes in building use may result in higher premiums or policy exclusions. Liability concerns, such as tenant safety and fire protection, also require comprehensive coverage. Additionally, the risk of work stoppages due to unforeseen environmental hazards, such as asbestos or mold, can result in financial setbacks if not adequately insured.

The inability to secure fair insurance claims can create financial strain, especially if developers have planned for insurance payouts to mitigate risks. Ensuring comprehensive coverage, addressing potential liabilities, and understanding policy limitations are crucial steps in managing the financial risks of conversion projects.

Converting existing buildings into residential spaces can be both rewarding and profitable, but it requires careful planning, foresight, and an understanding of various challenges. From infrastructure modifications and zoning hurdles to financial feasibility and insurance complexities, developers must be prepared to navigate a complex landscape.